The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources

If one were to take into account the news reports from 150 years ago in the South on the attempts to cause the slaves to rise up and do bodily harm to non slaves, it may make one think that arming said slaves would have been a real cause for concern after the war began. We read in the news you posted on the abolitionist stirring the pot and that was from just a small number of the many newspapers in circulation at that time. There quite possibly have been more. If there were an occasional FMC in a regiment, it may not have been a problem. They did, and some slaves did fight in the Revolutionary War.

I'm not convinced that all of the records from the Confederate Army and/or Government were saved. We know of the many courthouse fires that destroyed 'evidence'. We know there was a lot of confusion after Lee met Grant. I would assume there's a good chance that a lot of paperwork was tossed on the fire and we have no way of knowing just what it all contained.

Perhaps during some of the fighting the drovers or other Blacks that were 'there' took up arms and it was for self preservation during those incidents. It doesn't make sense to me that, other than a few exceptions, there were slaves doing any fighting in a formal, trained format. Unless someone pulls a rabbit out of the hat, we're not going to see any proof that could stand up to real scrutiny on the matter. It could have happened, but we have no primary source to show it did. I'm still thinking the pre-war activity by the abolitionist in trying to get the slaves to harm their owner is a sound reason for them to reject that on a large scale. Considering the ordinary infantrymans day on the battle field, if there were armed slaves, they probably would have had to watch their front and their back. Since a large number of them did not own slaves, that may have been asking a bit much for the common soldier.

Pam

Messages In This Thread

Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
ps
Re: Bob Bradley - ADAH
Re: Bob Bradley - ADAH
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
From the Hawkinsville Dispatch
Re: From the Hawkinsville Dispatch
George Martin
Re: George Martin
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Myth = Strawman
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources
Re: Review of Black Confederate Sources