In 1870 or 1871 John Watt De Peyster published an article on the career of former COnfederate officer Maj. Gen. William Mahone.

Jubal A. Early attacked the article in print.

De Peyster revised the article in theJuly, 1871 issue of Historical Magazine.

I'd like to obtain all the articles involved in this controversy

Bryce A. Suderow
streetstories@juno.com