The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n

You still fail to take into account the Dred Scott ruling in regards to the rights of Slave owners when talking about the Southerners reaction to Douglas' "Squartters Sovernity" policy. It was seen as another way to control the slave states by making every territory a "bleeding Kansas" in which settlers who owned slaves would be left unprotected and discouraged from settling in that territory by the 'John Brown' types.

The southeners dislike of Douglas's policy was still rooted in U.S. Supreme Court rulings, U.S. federal Laws, and the U.S. Constitution from which these laws and rulings stemed from. As demonstrated by the election of Lincoln, the Slave states did not have the political power to change anything. But to change the laws "legally" the Constitution had to be change, hence the 13th amendment. That was made very unlikely by the 1820 Missouri Compromise provisions until those were struck down by the Dred Scott ruling.

Yes, It was about Slavery, but it wasn't about slavery. lt was only about slavery as it pertained to the rule of law and equal protection of all citizens rights by the United States Government not only in the States, but in the territories also. The 1860 election wasn't about secession. But, it was about Constitutional Governance and the right to the protections guaranteed under that Constitution.

When Constitutional protections are voided what recourse is there left to the people? So in that way, the 1860 election was about secession. For example South Carolina's declaration to seceed, if Lincoln won that election. Why did South Carolina make such a declaration? Because they felt that Lincoln's election would insure the abrogation the rule of law and void those Constitutional protections.

The power of the Constitution of this country is that, if properly enforced, it gives the most protection to those who are the minority, or hold to the least popular practices, or ideals.

Messages In This Thread

Who favored Secession...Slave or Non-slave owners
Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did not *NM*
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Slaveholder Expeditions to Kansas, 1850s
Re: Slaveholder Expeditions to Kansas, 1850s
Re: Slaveholder Expeditions to Kansas, 1850s
Re: Slaveholder Expeditions to Kansas, 1850s
Re: Slaveholder Expeditions to Kansas, 1850s
Re: Slaveholder Expeditions to Kansas, 1850s
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Or ..Those who owned slaves or those who did n
Re: Who favored Secession...Slave or Non-slave own
Re: Who favored Secession...Slave or Non-slave own
Re: Who favored Secession...Slave or Non-slave own
Re: Who favored Secession...Slave or Non-slave own
Re: Who favored Secession...Slave or Non-slave own
Re: Who favored Secession...Slave or Non-slave own
Re: Who favored Secession...Slave or Non-slave own