The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM

Agreed. One of the reason why I do not personally like the Confederate Government was they went against the wishes of the people for too long. Several states ignored the wishes of the Richmond government and allowed Blacks into the ranks to serve. There is a rich history of Slave owning Southerners fighting side by side with Blacks (i.e. the Revolution, and the War of 1812). It was a corps of New Orleans Black militia that was credited with doing the most damage to the center of the British forces storming Andy Jacksons line of battle, and killing the British general.

However, I dig deeper. Secession was never intended to protect slavery, for secession was the true goal, slavery was a red herring. Secession or disunion was the goal of both the fire-eaters and the abolitionist.

1. As far back as the 1820s there was a movement by idealogs of seperation of North and South. Several different causes were tried and failed (nullification, state admissions, foreign wars) but the one that stuck was the issue of slavery. See Andrew Jackson's own words on the subject.
2. Secession actually accerated the end of slavery, it could not protect it, it could not expand it, it could not control it. This was obvious to many Southerners, especially slave owners.
3. The wording of documents constantly expressing the devotion to the slavery cause is an overblown attempt to remind people what they were angry about, this practice evaporates from the bulk of official documents and the media after Fort Sumter.

__________________________
David Upton

Messages In This Thread

Lee's View January 1865
Cleburne's View -- January 1863
Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
What about this JAKEo??
Re: What about this JAKEo??
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What's This About?
Re: What's This About?
Re: What's This About?
Re: What's This About?
Re: What's This About?
Re: What's This About?
Re: 1st Choctaw Battn. of Mississippi
Re: 1st Choctaw Battn. of Mississippi
Re: 1st Choctaw Battn. of Mississippi
Re: 1st Choctaw Battn. of Mississippi
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Re: What about this JAKEo?? HEY JIM
Four years after Secession
Thanks For Your Service!
Re: What Did They Really Debate?
Re: What Did They Really Debate?
Re: What Did They Really Debate?
Re: What Did They Really Debate?
Re: What Did They Really Debate?
Re: What Did They Really Debate?
Re: What Did They Really Debate?
Re: What Did They Really Debate?
Re: What Did They Really Debate?
Re: What Did They Really Debate?
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
Re: Charleston's View -- January 1865
JAKEo read slowly and carefully.
Re: JAKEo read slowly and carefully.