Unfortunatley, the American Civil War Research Database list only two men who surrendered with the 23rd Alabama, Consolidated

John M. Bruce

Residence was not listed; 15 years old.
Enlisted on 5/8/1862 as a Private.
On 5/8/1862 he mustered into "F" Co. AL 23rd Infantry
He was transferred out on 4/9/1865 at Smithfield, NC
On 4/9/1865 he transferred into "F" Co. AL 23rd Cons Infantry
He was Surrendered on 4/26/1865 at Durham Station, NC
Other Information:
born 8/5/1846 in Alabama
died 10/2/1867 in Carroll County, MS
Buried: New Shiloh Baptist Cemetery, Carrollton, MS

…..

Hector McKenzie Graham

Residence was not listed; 24 years old.
Enlisted on 3/25/1861 as a Captain.
On 3/25/1861 he was commissioned into "E" Co. AL 23rd Infantry
He was transferred out on 4/9/1865 at Smithfield, NC
On 4/9/1865 he transferred into "E" Co. AL 23rd Cons Infantry
He was Surrendered on 4/26/1865 at Durham Station, NC
Other Information:
born 2/2/1837 in Monroeville, AL
died 5/8/1907 in Bay St Louis, MS
Buried: Crdar Rest Cemetery, Bay St Louis, MS

Sources used by Historical Data Systems, Inc.:
- Index to Compiled Confederate Military Service Records
- Mississippi Confederate Grave Registry

…………….

On April 9, 1865, the Twenty-third Alabama Infantry was consolidated with the 31st and 46th Alabama Infantry Regiments to form the Twenty-third Alabama Infantry Regiment (Consolidated). On April 12, 1865, the Regiment was ordered to move to Salisbury, North Carolina, in response to General Stoneman's cavalry raid from Tennessee. The Regiment remained there until April 26, 1865, when it was surrendered by General Johnston along with the rest of his army. Throughout the war, over 1200 men served under the Regiment's colors at one time or another, but only 76 soldiers remained to surrender with the gallant Army of Tennessee.
http://www.canerossi.us/23ala/part2.htm